Sunday, October 11, 2026

AFTER YOU'D GONE by Maggie O'Farrell

Three generations of characters and a bouncy timeline make for a challenging but enjoyable read, even though the prologue begins with an attempted suicide by Alice, the main character.  We gradually learn her story from her reflections while in a coma, as well as third-person narration that often changes abruptly in both perspective and time period.  The author relies on context to get us settled into the right situation, and it works OK, although I didn’t really love having to wrap my head around what has happened and what is yet to happen in each scenario.  The crux of the novel is an epic love story between Alice and John, but why Alice tries to kill herself is a story that unfolds slowly, along with a family secret that has been withheld way too long.  Some parts of the novel are extremely romantic and other parts on extremely heartbreaking.  Frankly, I could have done with more romance and less heartbreak, which is actually more like soul-crushing grief.  Still, this is a book I always looked forward to resuming, partly because questions remained unanswered until the end but also because Alice was such a delightful and lovable character.  I wanted the best possible outcome for her.

No comments: