Monday, November 30, 2020
ADVENTURES OF HUCKLEBERRY FINN by Mark Twain
The Southern dialect dialog keeps this picaresque classic
from being a fast read, and I think now it might work better as an
audiobook. Still, I plodded my way
through and enjoyed the irony, humor, and adventure that his book offers. Why on earth did we read this as kids, aside
from the fact that the title character is a 14-year-old boy? Jim, a runaway slave, has in his head a
gazillion superstitions, and Huck seems to run afoul of all of them, courting
bad luck at every turn and never knowing when the bad luck has ended. The escapades of Huck, Tom, Jim, and two
despicable con men are often silly, but sometimes the results are dire. This novel has quite a bit of violence,
including a murder in cold blood and a family feud that practically wipes out
both sides, with neither family really sure about the origin of their
disagreement. After a particularly
deadly encounter, the families attend a church service in which the sermon’s
message is brotherly love! Their animosity,
juxtaposed with their fundamentalist religion, would seem ridiculously
hypocritical if it didn’t hit so close to home for so many disputes today and
throughout history. On the lighter side,
Hamlet’s soliloquy is hilariously misquoted and interleaved with passages from Macbeth and possibly other works, for
all I know. Ultimately, though, this is
a story of the bond that develops between Huck and Jim. Huck’s sense of right and wrong is constantly
challenged, due to his misguided conviction that the right thing to do is to
return Jim to his owner. However, his
loyalty to Jim and his doubt that he is destined for heaven anyway cause him to
act on Jim’s behalf time and again.
These two naïve souls have each other’s back, protecting one another
both physically and emotionally.
Wednesday, November 25, 2020
THE GUEST BOOK by Sarah Blake
One thing that annoyed me about this novel was the author’s
overuse of the word “ranged” or “ranging.”
She uses “range” as a verb twenty times, and not in the way I would use
it, such as in “a number ranging from one to a hundred.” Perhaps this word usage is common to people
who come from old money, and that’s why it seemed so odd to me. This novel is indeed about old money, as in
buying an island off the coast of Maine during the Great Depression. Three generations of the Milton family have
enjoyed summers on this island, with varying levels of attachment to it. Evie is the modern-day character who wants to
hold on to the island, not matter what the cost, but not all of her cousins
agree. As in many fictional family
sagas, secrets abound, and even after I finished the novel I was unsure what
Evie knew about her family’s past and what she didn’t. For example, her grandmother Kitty’s
firstborn son plunges through the window from the 14th floor of
their apartment early in the book, but I was never sure whether subsequent
generations knew about this accident.
They were, however, certainly aware that Kitty’s second son, Moss, died
in his 20s in 1959, and the circumstances of his death are not revealed until
the end of the novel. Besides the fact
that I could not relate to these people and their problems at all, I felt that
the author was particularly hard on the characters of her own gender. The women are mostly buttoned up and
resistant to change, overly concerned with wallpaper and upholstery fabric,
whereas the men are more open-minded, despite some unsavory business
alliances. At almost 500 pages, this
novel spends way too much time describing the contents of the island house, and
I just wanted to get on with the story.
Things do pick up in the last 100 pages, but not enough for me to
declare that reading the first 400 pages was time well spent.
Wednesday, November 18, 2020
RED CLOCKS by Leni Zumas
Teenage girls who seek abortions are imprisoned, and
abortionists face the death penalty.
This novel gives us a glimpse into the lives of four women in the not so
distant future after Roe v. Wade has
been overturned. The characters are the
wife (Susan), the biographer (Ro), the daughter (Mattie—no relation to Susan),
and the mender (Gin). A law school
dropout, Susan loves her two small children but hates her life to the point
that she contemplates driving off a cliff.
She would like a divorce, partly so that her husband can take the kids
on weekends, but she does not want to initiate it. Ro, on the other hand, envies Susan’s life
and, at 42, is trying to have a child via artificial insemination. She would settle for adoption, but as a
single parent, her chances are slim, and soon such adoptions will be
illegal. Mattie is 16, herself adopted,
and pregnant, and would like to have the fetus ripped from her body by any
means possible. Gin is a purveyor of herbal
remedies and is Mattie’s biological mother, although Mattie is unaware of their
relationship. These women each command
their own chapters, which are interleaved with the journal entries of a female
arctic explorer—the subject of the biography that Ro is writing. I did not grasp the significance of these
interruptions, which I felt disturbed the continuity of the book. Other than that, I loved it, especially the
contrast between Ro’s and Susan’s lives.
Both are on the brink of total despair and want what the other has. What I found so scary about this novel is how
these women’s lives seemed pretty familiar, except for Gin’s, since she lives
in a cabin in the woods. Then the stark
reality of how much these strict parenthood laws have cost them becomes
apparent and extremely frightening.
Wednesday, November 11, 2020
THE WATER DANCER by Ta-Nehisi Coates
Hiram Walker is a young slave on a Virginia tobacco
plantation in the mid-1800s. His white
father owns the plantation and positions Hiram to be the manservant of Hiram’s
white half-brother Maynard. While being
groomed for this job, Hiram learns to read and to take advantage of and exhibit
his photographic memory. Hiram has
another talent, known as “conduction” in the novel, which allows him to
teleport himself from one place to another.
I have to say that this magical realism aspect of the novel does not really
add any particular value. It seems very
Harry Potter-like for what is undoubtedly a very serious novel. It takes some time for Hiram to fully corral
this ability, and, in the meantime, he has a number of adventures, both
pleasant and terrifying. The problem
with this book is that, despite all of Hiram’s ups and downs, it drags. This author has a reputation for non-fiction
and perhaps needs to hone his ability to engage the reader with suspense and
concern for the fate of the characters.
I did care what happened to Hiram, but I was not inspired to pick up the
book and find out. I trudged through it,
delighted by the Harriet Tubman cameo, and worried for Hiram’s safety from
start to finish. However, we know from
his first-person narrative that Hiram survives into old age, and I found that
knowledge comforting but not exactly conducive to a nail-biting
experience. Still, there’s a lot of good
stuff here, including a love story, a massive betrayal, and a heartwarming
reunification. Then there’s the ugly
truth of slavery that we get to witness through the eyes of a young man who
gains and shares a wide-angle perspective.
Wednesday, November 4, 2020
HOUSE ON ENDLESS WATERS by Emuna Elon
Yoel Blum is a well-known Israeli writer who returns to
Amsterdam, the city of his birth, to research a novel about his past. We know that his mother Sonia escaped the
Holocaust with her daughter Nettie, and Yoel, who has discovered that Sonia
apparently left another child behind.
Some reviewers have called this a family mystery, but the mystery is not
so much about what happened, as that seemed obvious to me, but how it happens. Yoel has prodded his sister for details after
his mother’s death, and her explanation fuels Yoel’s imagination in the writing
of his novel, although we readers are enlightened only by the text of Yoel’s
novel as it progresses. He rents a small
hotel room in the neighborhood where Sonia lived so that he can immerse himself
both physically and emotionally in her story.
This book, then, is actually two stories—Sonia’s and Yoel’s—with almost
seamless switching between the two. Sonia’s
life deteriorates little by little into a harrowing existence as she endeavors
to save her family from a demise that she can hardly believe is coming. A
revelation at the end explains why Yoel’s mother was so secretive about the
past, but that was not particularly surprising, either. What makes this book special is how personal the
story feels. Sonia’s heartbreak as she
wrestles with impossible decisions is palpable and so gut-wrenching that I was
immensely glad to know from the beginning that she survives. This book is a true reminder that the
experiences of Sonia’s family, grappling with life and death choices regarding
the welfare of themselves and their children, were not unique. I cannot begin to imagine what their lives
were like, but this book provides a small window into that horror.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)